Entertainment

How To Watch The Murdoch Trial

how-to-watch-the-murdoch-trial

What Is the Murdoch Trial?

The Murdoch Trial refers to the legal proceedings involving media mogul Rupert Murdoch and his company, News Corporation. The trial focuses on allegations of phone hacking, bribery, and other illegal activities carried out by individuals associated with Murdoch’s media empire.

At its core, the trial aims to uncover the truth behind the systemic invasion of privacy and unethical practices that occurred within News Corporation’s British newspapers, most notably the now-defunct News of the World. These actions not only violated the privacy of numerous individuals but also compromised the integrity of journalism.

The scandal broke in 2011 when it was revealed that journalists at News of the World had been engaging in phone hacking, illegally accessing voicemails of various high-profile individuals, including celebrities, politicians, and even crime victims. As the investigation progressed, evidence emerged suggesting a widespread culture of misconduct and corruption within the organization.

The fallout from the scandal led to the closure of News of the World and resulted in criminal charges against several individuals, including journalists, editors, and executives. Rupert Murdoch and his son James Murdoch, who was the chief executive of News International, the British newspaper division of News Corporation, were also called to testify before the British Parliament.

The Murdoch Trial represents a significant moment in the history of media and journalism ethics. It brings to light the importance of upholding the principles of truth, integrity, and privacy within the media industry. The trial serves as a reminder that even powerful media organizations must be held accountable for their actions and that no one is above the law.

The proceedings surrounding the Murdoch Trial have garnered substantial media attention and public scrutiny. The outcome of the trial could have far-reaching implications not only for Rupert Murdoch and his media empire but also for the broader media landscape as a whole.

As the trial unfolds, it will be crucial to closely follow the developments, witnesses’ testimonies, and court decisions to gain a deeper understanding of the extent of the wrongdoing and the potential consequences for those involved.

Background of the Murdoch Trial

The Murdoch Trial stems from a long history of controversy surrounding media tycoon Rupert Murdoch and his media empire. Murdoch, the founder and former chairman of News Corporation, built a vast media empire that includes newspapers, television networks, and film studios.

The roots of the Murdoch Trial can be traced back to 2011 when The Guardian newspaper first reported allegations that journalists at News of the World had engaged in illegal phone hacking. This initial revelation sparked a chain of events that led to a widespread investigation and exposed a culture of misconduct within Murdoch’s media empire.

As the investigation unfolded, it was revealed that journalists employed by News of the World had hacked into the phones of not only celebrities but also crime victims and politicians. This breach of privacy shocked the public and brought scrutiny upon the practices of Murdoch’s media outlets.

The scandal prompted a series of inquiries and investigations in the United Kingdom. The Leveson Inquiry, headed by Lord Justice Leveson, explored the culture, practices, and ethics of the British press in the wake of the phone-hacking scandal. The inquiry’s findings highlighted the need for regulatory changes and stricter industry standards.

Parallel to the Leveson Inquiry, criminal investigations were launched, resulting in the arrest and prosecution of several individuals connected to the phone-hacking activities. The trials that followed led to guilty verdicts and prison sentences for some journalists and editors involved.

However, the scope of the scandal was not limited to the phone-hacking allegations. Bribery and corruption charges were also leveled against Murdoch’s media empire. It was alleged that employees had made illegal payments to police officers and public officials in exchange for information and favors.

Rupert Murdoch and his son James Murdoch were not immune to the fallout. Both were called to testify before the British Parliament’s Culture, Media, and Sport Committee in 2011. Their appearances raised further questions about their knowledge and involvement in the illegal activities carried out by their employees.

The revelations surrounding the scandal sparked public outrage and prompted calls for stronger media regulation. The Murdoch Trial was seen as an opportunity to hold those responsible accountable and to bring about systemic changes within the media industry.

The trial itself would examine the evidence against Murdoch and his media empire, shedding light on the extent of their wrongdoing and exposing the ethical lapses that had permeated their operations.

With the background and context of the Murdoch Trial established, it is crucial to explore the key players involved and the timeline of events to gain a comprehensive understanding of this high-profile legal proceeding.

Key Players in the Murdoch Trial

The Murdoch Trial involves a cast of influential individuals who have played significant roles in the media empire owned by Rupert Murdoch. Understanding the key players is crucial to comprehending the dynamics and stakes involved in the trial.

Rupert Murdoch: Rupert Murdoch is a media mogul and the founder of News Corporation, which includes numerous media outlets worldwide. As the central figure in the Murdoch Trial, he is under scrutiny for his oversight of the company and its alleged unethical practices.

James Murdoch: James Murdoch is Rupert Murdoch’s son and a former executive at News Corporation. He held various prominent positions within the company, including being the chairman of News International, the British newspaper division. James Murdoch’s involvement in the trial focuses on his knowledge and handling of the phone-hacking scandal.

Rebekah Brooks: Rebekah Brooks, formerly known as Rebekah Wade, served as the chief executive of News International at the time of the phone-hacking scandal. She was a key figure in the British newspaper division and faced charges related to phone hacking and obstructing justice.

Andy Coulson: Andy Coulson was the former editor of News of the World and later served as the director of communications for the British Prime Minister, David Cameron. He faced charges relating to phone hacking and bribery during the trial.

Other Journalists and Editors: Numerous journalists and editors who worked for News Corporation’s British newspapers, especially News of the World, were implicated in the illegal activities at the center of the trial. Their roles in phone hacking, bribery, and other offenses have been subject to investigation and prosecution.

Victims and Whistleblowers: The Murdoch Trial also involves victims of phone hacking and individuals who blew the whistle on the illegal practices. These include celebrities, politicians, crime victims, and others whose privacy was violated by the actions of News Corporation journalists.

Prosecution and Legal Teams: The prosecution and legal teams are responsible for presenting the case against the defendants and seeking justice for the victims. These teams comprise skilled lawyers, investigators, and experts who work diligently to build a compelling case.

Judges and Court Personnel: The judges and court personnel presiding over the trial play a crucial role in ensuring fair proceedings and making legal determinations. Their decisions and rulings shape the trajectory and outcome of the trial.

These key players, along with their respective roles and actions, will shape the narrative of the Murdoch Trial. As the trial unfolds, the focus will remain on their testimonies, cross-examinations, and the evidence presented, as the court seeks to determine the truth behind the allegations of phone hacking, bribery, and other illegal activities.

Important Dates and Timeline of the Murdoch Trial

The Murdoch Trial has been a long and complex legal process, marked by significant events and milestones. Understanding the timeline of the trial is essential to grasp the progression of the case and the key developments that have taken place.

2011: The phone-hacking scandal at News of the World breaks, with revelations of illegal phone hacking by journalists employed by the newspaper. The scandal prompts investigations and inquiries into the practices and ethics of Rupert Murdoch’s media empire.

2012: The Leveson Inquiry into the culture, practices, and ethics of the British press is launched as a response to the phone-hacking scandal. The inquiry lasts for several months, hearing from witnesses and experts involved in the media industry.

2013: In June, the trial begins, with several key figures, including Rebekah Brooks and Andy Coulson, facing charges relating to phone hacking, bribery, and obstruction of justice. The trial attracts significant media attention and public interest.

2014: In June, after a lengthy trial and deliberation, Rebekah Brooks is acquitted of all charges, while Andy Coulson is found guilty of conspiracy to hack phones and sentenced to prison. Other individuals associated with News of the World also face conviction or acquittal.

2015: The second part of the trial, known as Operation Elveden, commences. This phase focuses on charges of bribery and corruption involving payments made to public officials in exchange for information. The trial further exposes the extent of illicit practices within News Corporation.

2017: The trial concludes with various verdicts and sentences, including convictions for bribery and corruption-related offenses. The legal aftermath of the trial continues as appeals and subsequent legal actions take place.

2019: The Court of Appeal quashes the convictions of three individuals, including Rebekah Brooks, citing legal errors in the previous trial. As a result, a retrial is ordered for these individuals.

2021: The retrial begins, once again bringing attention to the ongoing legal battle related to the Murdoch Trial. The proceedings evaluate new evidence and examine the revised charges against those involved.

Throughout the course of the trial, there have been numerous hearings, testimonies, and verdicts that have shaped the narrative and outcome of the case. The importance of these dates and events cannot be understated, as they demonstrate the complexity of the legal proceedings and the impact they have had on the media landscape.

As the trial continues to unfold, it is crucial to closely follow the developments and legal decisions to gain a comprehensive understanding of the implications for both the individuals involved and the broader media industry.

Where Is the Murdoch Trial Being Held?

The Murdoch Trial is being held in the United Kingdom, specifically in various courts within the jurisdiction of the British legal system. Given the significance and scope of the trial, multiple courts have been involved in handling different aspects of the legal proceedings.

Various stages of the trial have taken place in different courtrooms, each with its specific purpose and jurisdiction. The locations of the trial proceedings have played an important role in ensuring a fair and transparent legal process.

The initial hearings and trials pertaining to the phone-hacking scandal took place at the Central Criminal Court of England and Wales, better known as the Old Bailey. The Old Bailey, located in London, is a historic and renowned courthouse known for handling high-profile criminal cases.

As the trial progressed, additional hearings and proceedings took place in other courts across the United Kingdom. This ensured that the legal process was accessible and fair for all parties involved.

Throughout the course of the trial, various courtrooms and venues may have been utilized based on the nature of the specific legal proceedings. These may include Crown Courts, which handle serious criminal cases, as well as magistrates’ courts and other specialized courts based on the charges being faced by the defendants.

It is worth noting that due to the high-profile nature of the case, the courtroom proceedings have attracted significant media attention. Journalists and media organizations have closely followed the trial and reported on the developments, further highlighting the importance of transparency and accountability in the legal proceedings.

While the specific location of the trial may vary depending on the stage and nature of the proceedings, the overall objective is to ensure a fair and impartial trial within the confines of the British legal system. This includes guaranteeing proper legal representation, conducting hearings in public, and affording all parties the opportunity to present their case.

The physical locations of the Murdoch Trial have served as the backdrop for the legal battle, highlighting the importance of the rule of law and the pursuit of justice. It is within these courthouses that the evidence has been presented, witnesses have been called to testify, and the truth has been sought.

As the trial progresses, the location of the proceedings will continue to be significant, serving as a reminder of the legal framework in which the trial is taking place and the importance of the judicial process in holding accountable those responsible for the alleged misconduct within Rupert Murdoch’s media empire.

How Can You Watch the Murdoch Trial?

If you’re interested in following the proceedings of the Murdoch Trial, there are several ways to watch or access updates on the trial. Whether you prefer live coverage, highlights, or analysis, here are some options to consider:

1. Live Streaming: Many news outlets and media organizations provide live streaming of high-profile trials, including the Murdoch Trial. Check the websites of reputable news sources or news channels to see if they offer live coverage of the trial.

2. News Channels: Tune into news channels that frequently cover legal proceedings. Channels like BBC, CNN, Sky News, and Al Jazeera often provide updates, analysis, and commentary on significant trials.

3. Online Websites: Visit news websites that have dedicated sections or pages for court proceedings. These websites may provide live updates, articles, videos, and analysis related to the Murdoch Trial.

4. Social Media: Follow reputable news organizations, journalists, and legal experts on social media platforms like Twitter, Facebook, and LinkedIn. They often provide real-time updates and analysis on trials, including the Murdoch Trial.

5. Court Websites and Transcripts: Some courts make trial transcripts and other relevant documents available on their official websites. Check the court’s website for any public access to documents or transcripts related to the Murdoch Trial.

6. Podcasts and Radio: Look for podcasts dedicated to legal analysis or specific trials. Additionally, some radio stations offer coverage of significant trials, allowing you to listen to the trial proceedings or analysis on the go.

7. News Apps: Install news apps on your smartphone or tablet to receive notifications and updates on the Murdoch Trial. Set up alerts for specific keywords or topics to receive timely updates directly to your device.

8. Legal Analysis Programs: Some television networks and online platforms host legal analysis programs that discuss and dissect trials. These programs often feature legal experts who provide insights and commentary on the Murdoch Trial.

It’s important to note that the availability of trial coverage may vary depending on your location, the prominence of the trial, and the media landscape. It’s recommended to rely on reputable sources and news organizations to ensure accurate and up-to-date information.

By utilizing these resources, you can stay informed about the latest developments, witness testimonies, and the overall progress of the Murdoch Trial. Remember to consider multiple sources and perspectives to gain a comprehensive understanding of the trial and its implications.

Live Streaming Options for the Murdoch Trial

If you want to watch the Murdoch Trial live, there are several options available for live streaming the trial proceedings. These platforms allow you to tune in to the trial in real-time, ensuring that you don’t miss any critical moments or testimonies. Here are some live streaming options to consider:

1. News Websites and Apps: Visit the websites or download the apps of reputable news organizations that cover the trial. Many news outlets offer live streaming of the trial proceedings on their websites or within their dedicated news apps.

2. YouTube Live: Some news organizations or legal channels may stream the Murdoch Trial live on YouTube. By subscribing to their channels or searching for live streams related to the trial, you can access the proceedings in real-time.

3. Court Websites: Check the official website of the court where the trial is being held. Some courts provide live streaming of significant trials on their websites to ensure transparency and accessibility to the public.

4. Social Media Platforms: Stay updated on the trial by following reputable news organizations or legal commentators on social media platforms like Twitter, Facebook, or Instagram. They may provide live streams or real-time updates on the trial proceedings.

5. Television Channels and Networks: Tune into television channels that often cover high-profile trials. Channels like BBC, CNN, Sky News, or Al Jazeera may provide live coverage or dedicate segments to the Murdoch Trial.

6. Legal Streaming Services: Some online platforms specialize in live streaming legal proceedings. These platforms may offer live coverage of the Murdoch Trial, enabling you to watch the trial in real-time from your computer or mobile device.

It’s essential to note that the availability of live streaming options may vary depending on your location and the media coverage of the trial. It’s advisable to explore multiple sources and platforms to ensure access to reliable and uninterrupted live coverage of the Murdoch Trial.

By utilizing these live streaming options, you can stay engaged with the trial proceedings, witness crucial testimonies, and gain firsthand insights into the legal battle surrounding the allegations made against Rupert Murdoch and his media empire.

Accessing Court Transcripts and Documents

Accessing court transcripts and documents is crucial for those interested in obtaining a comprehensive understanding of the proceedings and details of the Murdoch Trial. These records provide valuable insights into witness testimonies, legal arguments, and court decisions. Here are some ways to access court transcripts and documents related to the trial:

1. Court Websites: Visit the official website of the court where the Murdoch Trial is being held. Some courts provide public access to court documents, including transcripts, pleadings, exhibits, and judgments. These documents may be available for download or viewing on the court’s website under a designated section for the trial.

2. Online Legal Databases: Utilize online legal databases that offer access to court records, including transcripts and related documents. Websites such as LexisNexis, Westlaw, or Bloomberg Law often provide comprehensive coverage of notable trials and may have the transcripts available for research purposes.

3. News Outlets: Stay informed through reputable news outlets that cover the Murdoch Trial. These organizations often report on and publish excerpts of court transcripts, providing insight into the most critical and impactful moments of the trial. Accessing these news articles or interviews can give you a summary and analysis of the proceedings.

4. Freedom of Information Requests: In some cases, it may be possible to file a freedom of information request to obtain court transcripts and documents related to the Murdoch Trial. This process involves making a formal request to the appropriate court or legal authority for access to specific records. However, the availability and success of such requests may vary depending on jurisdiction and specific regulations.

5. Legal Research Centers or Libraries: Visit legal research centers or libraries that have comprehensive collections of legal materials and resources. These institutions often maintain archives of court transcripts and documents for notable trials. Researchers and legal professionals can sometimes access these materials upon request.

When accessing court transcripts and documents, it is essential to verify the reliability and authenticity of the sources. Relying on official court websites or reputable news outlets ensures that the information obtained is accurate and reflects the actual proceedings of the trial.

By accessing court transcripts and documents, you can delve deeper into the details, arguments, and evidence presented during the Murdoch Trial, allowing for a more comprehensive understanding of the case and the legal process involved.

News Sources Covering the Murdoch Trial

The Murdoch Trial has garnered significant media attention, and numerous news sources have dedicated resources to cover this high-profile legal proceeding. These news outlets provide extensive coverage, analysis, and updates on the trial, ensuring that the public stays informed about the latest developments. Here are some notable news sources covering the Murdoch Trial:

1. BBC: The British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) is known for its comprehensive coverage of significant national and international events. The BBC offers in-depth reporting, analysis, and interviews related to the Murdoch Trial, providing a reliable source of information.

2. The Guardian: The Guardian is a renowned British newspaper that broke the phone-hacking scandal, subsequently leading to the Murdoch Trial. The newspaper continues to cover the trial meticulously, offering insightful articles, live updates, and analysis related to the proceedings.

3. The New York Times: As a prominent international newspaper, The New York Times extensively covers the Murdoch Trial. Through its investigative journalism and expert analysis, it provides a global perspective on the trial, shedding light on its implications beyond the United Kingdom.

4. The Telegraph: The Telegraph is a British newspaper that offers comprehensive coverage of the Murdoch Trial. It includes updates, opinions, and commentary on the trial proceedings, providing a valuable source of information for those following the case.

5. The Independent: The Independent is another notable British newspaper that covers the Murdoch Trial extensively. With articles, interviews, and analysis, it provides a holistic view of the trial and its implications for the media industry.

6. Sky News: Sky News, a 24-hour news channel, provides real-time updates, interviews, and analysis related to the Murdoch Trial. It offers live coverage of significant moments during the trial, ensuring viewers stay informed about the proceedings.

7. Al Jazeera: Al Jazeera, an international news network, covers the Murdoch Trial, providing a distinct perspective on the trial’s global impact and its ramifications for the media industry. It offers comprehensive coverage and analysis through its website and news broadcasts.

These news sources deliver reliable and balanced coverage of the Murdoch Trial, offering a mix of factual reporting, interviews with legal experts, and analysis of the trial’s implications. By consulting multiple sources, individuals can obtain a more comprehensive view of the trial, its progress, and its significance in the media landscape.

It is important to note that news sources may differ in their editorial stance and coverage focus. Therefore, considering a variety of sources allows for a well-rounded understanding of the diverse perspectives surrounding the trial.

Analysis and Commentary on the Murdoch Trial

The Murdoch Trial has been the subject of extensive analysis and commentary from legal experts, journalists, and commentators. These individuals provide valuable insights, interpretations, and critiques of the trial proceedings, offering a deeper understanding of its significance. Here’s an overview of the analysis and commentary surrounding the Murdoch Trial:

Legal Experts: Prominent legal professionals, including lawyers, professors, and judges, provide analysis on the legal aspects of the trial. They offer interpretations of the evidence, assessments of witness testimonies, and predictions on potential legal outcomes. Their expertise provides valuable insights into the complex legal aspects of the trial.

Journalists and Reporters: Journalists and reporters who cover the trial provide on-the-ground reporting, summaries of proceedings, and interviews with key figures involved. Their analysis often includes broader context, exploring the connections between the trial and the media industry, ethics, and freedom of the press.

Media Ethicists: Ethical experts specializing in the field of media ethics offer thoughtful analysis of the trial’s implications for journalistic standards and practices. They examine the ethical implications of the alleged misconduct and discuss the need for accountability and responsible reporting within the media industry.

Opinion Writers: Opinion writers provide personal perspectives on the trial, offering interpretations and arguments on its significance. They may discuss the power dynamics within the media industry, the role of media moguls, or the impact of the trial on journalistic integrity. These viewpoints add depth to the public discourse surrounding the trial.

Political Commentators: Political commentators examine the political ramifications of the trial, including its implications for media regulation, government-media relations, and the broader influence of media conglomerates. They discuss the role played by politicians and the implications for public trust in institutions.

These analyses and commentaries provide additional context, insights, and perspectives on the Murdoch Trial beyond the factual reporting of the proceedings. Bringing diverse expertise and experiences, these individuals contribute to the broader understanding of the trial’s significance and its impact on the media landscape.

It is important to consider a range of analysis and commentary to gain a comprehensive understanding of the trial. By examining differing viewpoints, individuals can engage in a well-rounded discussion, critically evaluating the various perspectives and forming their own informed opinions on the Murdoch Trial.

What to Expect During the Murdoch Trial

The Murdoch Trial is a complex legal proceeding with several key elements that individuals can expect to see throughout the trial. Understanding what to anticipate during the trial is crucial for following the developments and gaining insight into the legal process. Here are some things to expect during the Murdoch Trial:

1. Witness Testimonies: As is typical in trials, witness testimonies play a central role in the Murdoch Trial. Expect to hear from individuals who were directly involved in or affected by the alleged illegal activities, including journalists, editors, whistleblowers, and victims. These testimonies shed light on the extent of the wrongdoing and provide crucial evidence for the case.

2. Cross-Examinations: Cross-examinations are a vital part of the trial process. Lawyers representing different parties will question the witnesses to test their credibility, challenge their statements, and probe for inconsistencies or gaps in their testimonies. Cross-examinations aim to establish the truth and assess the reliability of the evidence presented.

3. Presentation of Evidence: Throughout the trial, expect the presentation of documentary evidence, such as phone records, emails, financial documents, and other materials relevant to the alleged illegal activities. The prosecution and defense will introduce evidence to support their respective arguments and strengthen their case.

4. Legal Arguments: Lawyers representing the prosecution and defense will present legal arguments to advance their respective positions. These arguments may include interpretations of the law, case precedents, and legal principles relevant to the charges and proceedings of the trial.

5. Jury Deliberations (if applicable): If the trial involves a jury, expect to see the jury retiring to deliberate on the verdict once all the evidence has been presented and the legal arguments have been made. The jury’s deliberations are conducted in private, and they will ultimately determine the guilt or innocence of the accused based on the evidence presented in court.

6. Legal Rulings and Decisions: Throughout the trial, expect the presiding judge to make legal rulings and decisions on various matters, such as the admissibility of evidence, objections raised by the lawyers, and other procedural issues. These rulings help shape the course and conduct of the trial.

7. Media Coverage and Public Interest: Given the high-profile nature of the trial, extensive media coverage can be expected. Journalists and news outlets will provide updates on the trial’s progress, analysis of the evidence presented, and commentary on its implications. Public interest in the trial, especially regarding the media’s conduct and ethics, remains significant.

8. Lengthy Proceedings: Trials involving complex legal matters and multiple defendants can be lengthy. The Murdoch Trial may span months or even years, depending on the complexity of the case, the number of charges, and any legal challenges or appeals that may arise.

It is crucial to note that the actual proceedings may vary, and unexpected developments can occur during the trial. However, understanding these general expectations provides a framework for following and comprehending the Murdoch Trial as it progresses.

Recap and Highlights of Each Day’s Proceedings

The daily proceedings of the Murdoch Trial offer a glimpse into the courtroom drama and the unfolding events surrounding the case. Recap and highlights of each day’s proceedings provide a snapshot of significant moments during the trial. Here are examples of what you might expect in a daily recap:

Day 1: The trial begins with opening statements from the prosecution and defense. The prosecution outlines their case, emphasizing the alleged illegal activities, while the defense challenges the charges and presents their strategy. Witness testimonies may start, providing early insights into the evidence that will be presented.

Day 2-5: Cross-examinations of witnesses dominate these days. Lawyers meticulously question witnesses to establish credibility, challenge testimonies, and highlight inconsistencies. Key witnesses may provide compelling evidence, revealing details of the alleged illegal activities and their involvement.

Day 6-10: The prosecutor introduces documentary evidence, such as emails, phone records, or financial documents, to support their case. Experts may be called to testify, offering interpretations or analysis of the evidence. Legal arguments from the defense and prosecution intensify, shaping the narrative and potential outcomes.

Day 11-15: High-profile individuals, such as celebrities or politicians, testify as witnesses, drawing media attention. Their testimonies shed light on the impact of the alleged illegal activities and their interactions with the accused. Media coverage of these testimonies amplifies public interest in the trial.

Day 16-20: Additional evidence may be presented, including surveillance footage, audio recordings, or handwritten notes. The defense presents their case, challenging the prosecution’s evidence and raising alternative explanations. Closing arguments from both sides summarize their positions and attempt to sway the judge or jury.

Day 21-25: Deliberations begin, with the judge or jury evaluating the evidence and arguments to reach a verdict. The courtroom awaits the decision with anticipation, while media speculation and analysis of the trial’s outcome intensify.

Last Day: The trial concludes with the judge delivering the verdict. The courtroom reacts to the decision, and the media reports on the outcome. Legal experts provide analysis of the verdict and its implications for media ethics and accountability.

It’s important to note that these examples provide a general structure, and the actual proceedings and highlights may differ depending on the specifics of the trial. Each day’s recap and highlights offer a concise summary of significant moments, testimonies, evidence presented, and legal arguments that shaped the trial’s course.

Following the recap and highlights of each day’s proceedings ensures that you stay updated on the trial’s progress, key revelations, and any pivotal moments that arise during this closely-watched legal battle.